06/11/2026
Yes, this is a total loss.
I know it’s hard to believe, but here’s the truth: you can’t determine the extent of damage from a picture.
A customer from Iowa contacted me after her 2018 GMC Yukon XL Denali 4WD with 120,663 miles was declared a total loss by State Farm. She ran off the road into a ditch. At first glance, the body damage appeared minimal. However, the vehicle had taken on water, and the engine had hydrolocked.
In typical fashion, State Farm assured her, “No problem, we can fix it. It’ll be better than new.” Blah, blah, blah.
After spending over $15,000 attempting to repair the vehicle, electrical gremlins continued to appear. Eventually, it was determined that the Yukon needed a new engine. After months of delays and failed repair attempts, they suddenly shifted gears and started pressuring the owner to get out of the rental vehicle and accept their lowball total loss offer.
And, once again, the offer was based on the ever-unreliable CCC valuation report.
According to State Farm, the Yukon was worth only $22,647.
Looks like it was time to put “the Farm” out to pasture once again.
To State Farm’s credit, they did hire a reputable appraisal company. After a professional and productive discussion, we reached an agreement that the actual cash value of the Yukon was $29,500.
The result? The SUV owner got an additional $6,853
The lesson remains the same:
Never trust the people who owe you money to determine how much money they owe you.
If you’ve been told your vehicle is a total loss and something doesn’t seem right, get a free second opinion before accepting the insurance company’s offer.